Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857)
How Difficult is it to Become a Citizen?

Read through the details of the citizenship process.
  1. Identify two steps of the process that you consider most essential. For each of these steps, explain why that step is so important.

  2. Identify two steps of the process that you consider least essential. For each of these steps, explain why that step is not very important.

Before Applying

Candidates for naturalization must have been a permanent resident for the past five years, or three years if married to a U.S. citizen. An applicant must also be a person of "good moral character."
Examples of actions that might show a lack of good moral character:

  • Lying to gain immigration benefits
  • Illegal gambling
  • Failure to pay court-ordered child-support or alimony payments
  • Habitual drunkenness/drunken driving
  • Abuse of controlled substances
  • Prostitution
  • Polygamy
  • Any crime against a person with intent to harm
  • Terrorist acts

Applying
  1. Complete the ten-page Application for Naturalization (Form N_ 400)

  2. Have two photographs taken.

  3. Collect other necessary documents.
    • A photocopy of both sides of the Permanent Resident Card
    • A check or money order for the $260 processing fee

    Other documents that may be required:
    • Proof that a spouse has been a legal resident for at least three years
    • A marriage certificate
    • Proof of termination of a previous marriage
    • Certification of military service
    • Copies of court or government orders to provide financial support
    • Official records involving prior criminal charges
    • Income tax returns
    • Letter from a church attesting to applicant's "good moral character"

  4. Send the application, photos, documents, and fee to the appropriate service center.

  5. Receive an appointment letter from the INS for fingerprinting. If six months pass, your documents likely have been lost and you must reapply.

  6. Get fingerprints taken for FBI criminal background check.

  7. Wait for INS to schedule an interview; the wait can often be longer than a year.

  8. Receive an appointment for an interview. Applicants must take an English test to prove they can read, write, and speak English. They must also take a civics test. Applicants may be required by INS to provide additional documents.

  9. Decision, with three possible outcomes:

Granted: In some cases, the oath ceremony can take place the same day.

    If granted, the candidate will:

  • Receive a ceremony date to take the oath.
  • Return the Permanent Resident Card.
  • Take the Oath of Allegiance, renouncing allegiance to any foreign state or sovereignty.
  • Receive the Certificate of Naturalization.

Continued: Case is put on hold. Common reasons are failing the English and civics tests or failing to give the INS the needed documents.

Denied: There is an administrative review process for applicants who are denied.


Philip P. Pan, "Naturalization: An Unnatural Process Series: LA NUEVA
      VIDA; The Road to Citizenship; Third in an occasional series" The
Washington Post, Washington, D.C., Jul 4, 2000, p. A.1.
Resources
About landmarkcases.org
 
Teaching Recommendations
Based on Your Time

 
Background Summary
and Questions

• • •
Reading Level
• •
Reading Level
 •
Reading Level
 
Historical Background and Resources from "Africans in America" by PBS / WGBH
 
Diagram of How the Case Moved Through the Court System
 
Key Excerpts from the Majority Opinion
 
Key Excerpts from the Dissenting Opinion
 
Full Text of the Majority Opinion

back to top

Activities
    The Case
Read a Dred Scott Chronology
 
Trace Dred Scott's Travels on a U.S. Map
 
Classifying Arguments in the Case
 
Political Cartoon Analysis
 
Accounts from the Courtroom

back to top

    After the Case
Read Newspaper Editorials on the Supreme Court's Decision
 
Read Abraham Lincoln's Speech on the Dred Scott Decision
 
Read a Historian's Discussion of Dred Scott's Significance
 
Visit Dred Scott's Grave
 
How Difficult is it to Become a Citizen?

back to top

Back to top


  FindLaw  
 

LEGAL WEB AND DATABASE SEARCH