Hazelwood v.Kuhlmeier (1988)
Real World Case Study:
Censorship of a Student-Produced Television Show


Introduction

Should the policy that applies to a school's print media also apply to its broadcast media? Why or why not?

Directions:

  1. Read the article Student Press Protests Policy.
  2. Identify the following:
    • Facts of the case
    • Issue(s)
    • Arguments on both sides
  3. Look at the decision in Hazelwood Majority Opinion.
  4. If you were the students at Montgomery Blair High School, which arguments would you advance when presenting your case to the Board of Education? Why?
  5. If you were the officials at the education channel, which arguments would you advance when presenting your case to the Board of Education? Why?
  6. Read the articles Commission Works on Electronic Media Policy and Television Policy Finally Adopted at Blair High School. What was the county's final decision? Evaluate that decision.
  7. What impact will the decision have on future programming in Montgomery County?

After Effects Application

Read the article Story on Gay Teen Life Sparks Controversy.
  1. If you were the students, how would you make your case to the existing board?

  2. If you were on the board, what guidelines would you recommend?
Resources
About landmarkcases.org
 
Teaching Recommendations
Based on Your Time

 
Background Summary
and Questions

• • •
Reading Level
• •
Reading Level
 •
Reading Level
 
Diagram of How the Case Moved Through the Court System
 
Listen to the Oral Arguments
 
Key Excerpts from the Majority Opinion
 
Key Excerpts from the Dissenting Opinion
 
Full Text of the Majority Opinion
 

back to top

Activities
    The Case
You Decide: Were Students' Rights Violated?
 
What Would You Do?
 
Create Your Own Political Cartoon
 

back to top

    After the Case
Should the State Enact "Anti-Hazelwood" Legislation?
 
Evaluating Web Sites
 
Real World Case Study: Censorship of a Student-Produced Television Show
 

    Resources
The ACLU's Ask Sybil Liberty about Your Right to Free Expression
 
The SPLC's Complete Guide to the Supreme Court Decision
 
The Kansas Bar Foundation: Law Wise Newsletter featuring Students' Freedom of Expression under the First Amendment and Case on Point, Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier
 
The Freedom Forum's Analysis of Hazelwood's Impact on the Student Press
 
The SPLC's First Amendment Rights Diagram
 
The NSPA's Trends in High School Media
 
The SPLC's Cyberlaw and the Student Media
 

back to top

Back to top


  FindLaw  
 

LEGAL WEB AND DATABASE SEARCH